Navigating SAP Readiness Check Challenges in ECC to S/4HANA 2023 Migration

Transitioning from SAP ECC to SAP S/4HANA is a significant undertaking that necessitates meticulous planning and execution. The SAP Readiness Check serves as a pivotal tool in this process, offering a comprehensive assessment of the current system's preparedness for migration. However, executing the Readiness Check is not without its challenges. This analysis aims to dissect the complexities encountered during the RC execution, shedding light on the technical hurdles and the strategies employed to overcome them.
‍

The SAP Readiness Check Landscape
‍

The SAP Readiness Check is designed to evaluate various aspects of the existing ECC system, including:
‍

• Simplification Items: Identifying necessary adaptations due to changes in S/4HANA.
• Custom Code Analysis: Assessing custom developments for compatibility.
• Business Process Analytics: Analyzing current processes for optimization opportunities.
• Integration Checks: Ensuring seamless connectivity with other systems.
• Customer Vendor Integration (CVI): Preparing for the Business Partner approach in S/4HANA.

Successful execution of the RC requires the implementation of specific SAP Notes, updated system components, and adherence to a structured sequence of activities.
‍
‍

Challenges Encountered During RC Execution

Missing or Outdated SAP Notes
‍

Several critical SAP Notes were either missing or outdated, leading to incomplete or failed analyses:
‍

• SAP Note 2827612: Essential for the Innovation Potential analysis, providing insights into areas for future innovation based on current system usage.
• SAP Note 2903677: Enables the Effort Drivers for Simplification Items, assisting in estimating the effort required for necessary adaptations.
• SAP Note 2745851: Facilitates Business Process Analytics, offering a detailed view of process performance and potential improvements.
• SAP Note 3010669: Updates the Customer Vendor Integration Analysis, crucial for transitioning to the Business Partner model in S/4HANA.

Failure to implement these notes resulted in incomplete data collection and analysis, impeding the overall readiness assessment.
‍

Transport and SPAM Version Conflicts
‍

An error was encountered indicating that the transport-based correction SAPK61800NCPSAPAPPL required at least version 0071 of the Support Package Manager (SPAM). This incompatibility hindered the implementation of necessary corrections, emphasizing the importance of maintaining up-to-date system components.
‍
‍

Unfulfilled Prerequisites for Integration Scenarios
‍

The Readiness Check failed with the message: "Prerequisite for Integration not fulfilled. Check SAP Note 3061414 for more details."
‍

SAP Note 3061414 outlines prerequisites for integration checks, including the implementation of SAP Notes 3035012 and 3057501.
‍

Neglecting these prerequisites resulted in incomplete integration analysis, potentially overlooking critical issues in system connectivity.
‍
‍

Missing or Deprecated Function Modules
‍

The function module /SDF/START_DVM_RC_ANALYSIS was missing, necessitating the implementation of SAP Note 2612179.
‍

This module is vital for triggering and monitoring Data Volume Management (DVM) analyses, which are integral to understanding data growth and storage requirements in S/4HANA.
‍
‍

Runtime Dump Errors During Scheduling

Execution of the RC_COLLECT_ANALYSIS_DATA report led to runtime dumps:
‍

• DATA_OFFSET_NEGATIVE: Occurred when selecting "Interface" in the Scope Selection, as detailed in SAP Note 3006484.

• XSLT_BAD_SOURCE_CONTEXT: A runtime error during data transformation, addressed in SAP Note 2822563.

These errors disrupted the data collection process, highlighting the need for careful configuration and validation before execution.
‍
‍

Root Causes Behind the Issues

The challenges encountered can be attributed to several underlying factors:
‍

• Inadequate Pre-Checks: A lack of thorough system assessment before initiating the Readiness Check led to overlooked prerequisites and outdated components.
• Improper Sequencing of SAP Notes: Implementing notes out of the recommended order caused dependencies to fail, resulting in incomplete analyses.
• System Component Misalignment: Discrepancies between the system's current state and the requirements of the Readiness Check tools led to compatibility issues.
• Neglected Manual Steps: Some SAP Notes require manual activities post-implementation, which were missed, leading to partial configurations.
  ‍

Lessons Learned and Recommendations

Prioritize and Sequence SAP Notes Appropriately

Implementing SAP Notes in the correct sequence is crucial.

Begin with foundational notes like:
‍

• SAP Note 2745851: For Business Process Analytics.
• SAP Note 2827612: To enable Innovation Potential analysis.
• SAP Note 2903677: For Effort Drivers of Simplification Items.
• SAP Note 3010669: Updating the CVI Analysis.

Ensure all prerequisite notes, such as those outlined in SAP Note 3061414, are implemented beforehand.
‍

Validate System Components and Versions

Regularly update and verify system components like SPAM/SAINT to meet the requirements of the Readiness Check tools. Address any version conflicts promptly to prevent implementation errors.
‍

Utilize SAP Note Analyzer Tools

Leverage transaction SNOTE to identify and implement relevant SAP Notes. Use the "Notes with Manual Activities" view to ensure all necessary manual steps are completed.
‍

Conduct Mock Runs and Validate Configurations

Perform trial runs of the Readiness Check in a sandbox environment to identify and resolve potential issues before executing in the production system. This approach helps in catching errors like runtime dumps early in the process.
‍

Ensure Up-to-Date CVI and DVM APIs

Keep the Customer Vendor Integration and Data Volume Management APIs current by implementing the latest SAP Notes. This practice ensures accurate analyses and smooth transitions to the S/4HANA environment.
‍

Key Takeaways

• Preparation is Paramount: Thorough pre-checks and adherence to SAP's recommended procedures are essential for a successful Readiness Check.
• Stay Current: Regularly update system components and SAP Notes to align with the latest requirements and functionalities.
• Attention to Detail: Meticulously follow the implementation steps, including manual activities, to ensure comprehensive configurations.
• Proactive Testing: Utilize sandbox environments for testing to mitigate risks and identify issues early in the process.

In a Nutshell

Executing the SAP Readiness Check is a critical step in the journey from ECC to S/4HANA. While challenges are inevitable, understanding the intricacies of the process and adhering to best practices can significantly enhance the effectiveness of the assessment. By learning from the experiences detailed above, organizations can better prepare for their transition, ensuring a smoother and more efficient migration to SAP S/4HANA.

‍

‍